ÿþ<!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD XHTML 1.0 Transitional//EN" "http://www.w3.org/TR/xhtml1/DTD/xhtml1-transitional.dtd"> <html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml"> <head> <meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=iso-8859-1" /> <title>Patriot Week - Marbury v Madison</title> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="css/main_layout.css"> <link rel="shortcut icon" href="images/logo.ico" type="image/x-icon" /> </head> <body> <div id="wrapper"> <div id="header"> <div id="logo"></div> </div> <div id="main"> <div id="top_bg"></div><!--/top_bg--> <div id="content_bg"> <div id="content"> <!-- Navigation -------------------------------> <div id="nav"> <div id="nav_item1"> <div id="dropDownWrapper" class="menu_text"> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='index.html';"><a href="index.html">Home</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='first-principles.html';"><a href="first-principles.html">First Principles</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='founding-fathers-patriots.html';"><a href="founding-fathers-patriots.html">Founding Fathers/Patriots</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='activities.html';"><a href="activities.html">Activities</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='schedule.html';"><a href="schedule.html">Patriot Week Schedule</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <!--/menuItem--> <div id="redLine"></div> </div><!--/dropDownWrapper--> </div><!--/nav_item1--> <div id="nav_item2"> <div id="dropDownWrapper" class="menu_text"> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='materials-resources.html';"><a href="materials-resources.html">Materials and Resources</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='flags.html';"><a href="flags.html">Flags</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItemCurrentSub" onclick="location.href='documents-speeches.html';"><a href="documents-speeches.html">Documents and Speeches</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='original-constitution.html';"><a href="original-constitution.html">Original Constitution</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="redLine"></div> </div><!--/dropDownWrapper--> </div><!--/nav_item2--> <div id="nav_item3"> <div id="dropDownWrapper" class="menu_text"> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='2010-participants.html';"><a href="2010-participants.html">2010 Participants</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='2009-participants.html';"><a href="2009-participants.html">2009 Participants</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='organizing-committee.html';"><a href="board-of-directors.html">Board of Directors</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='advisory-board.html';"><a href="advisory-board.html">Advisory Board</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='about-judge-warren.html';"><a href="about-judge-warren.html">About Judge Michael Warren</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="redLine"></div> </div><!--/dropDownWrapper--> </div><!--/nav_item3--> <div id="nav_item4"> <div id="dropDownWrapper" class="menu_text"> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='media-clips.html';"><a href="media-clips.html">Media Clips</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='movies.html';"><a href="movies.html">Movies</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='michigan-senate-resolution.html';"><a href="michigan-senate-resolution.html">2009 Michigan Senate Resolution</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='2010-michigan-senate-resolution.html';"><a href="2010-michigan-senate-resolution.html">2010 Michigan Senate Resolution</a></div><!--/menuItem--> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='2011-Michigan-Senate-Resolution.html';"><a href="2011-Michigan-Senate-Resolution.html">2011 Michigan Senate Resolution</a></div> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='2010-michigan-house-resolution.html';"><a href="2010-michigan-house-resolution.html">2010 Michigan House Resolution</a></div> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='2011-michigan-house-bill-4464.htm';"><a href="2011-michigan-house-bill-4464.htm">2011 Michigan House Bill 4464</a></div> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='2011-Michigan-Senate-Bill-282.html';"><a href="2011-Michigan-Senate-Bill-282.html">2011 Michigan Senate Bill 282</a></div> <div id="line"></div> <div id="menuItem" onclick="location.href='newspaper-articles.html';"><a href="newspaper-articles.html">Newspaper Articles</a></div> <div id="redLine"></div> </div><!--/dropDownWrapper--> </div><!--/nav_item4--> <div id="nav_item5" onclick="location.href='join-the-effort.html';"><a href="join-the-effort.html"></a></div><!--/nav_item5--> <div id="nav_item6" onclick="location.href='2011-public-events.html';"><a href="2011-public-events.html"></a></div><!--/nav_item6--> </div><!--/nav--> <!-- End Navigation -------------------------------> <div style="clear:both"></div> <div id="mastheadLine"></div><!--/masthead--> <div id="mainWrapper"> <div id="left_column"> <div id="title"><img src="images/title_marbury_madison.gif" width="467" height="61" alt="Marbury v Madison" /></div> <div id="bodyBlock" class="body_text"> <strong class="quote">&ldquo;A law repugnant to the Constitution is void&rdquo;</strong> <br /><br /> <hr /> <br /><br /> <strong class="subTitle">Ensuring the Rule of Law</strong> <br /><br /> Perhaps the most important decision ever issued by the United States Supreme Court, <i>Marbury v Madison</i> addressed the issue of whether an act passed by Congress in conflict with the Constitution was valid. Ironically, the law at issue granted the United States Supreme Court original jurisdiction to hear a case (a writ of mandamus) brought by a judge who had been appointed by the prior President (John Adams) but who the current President (Thomas Jefferson) refused to provide the necessary paperwork to be seated. In an opinion written by Jefferson&#39;s distant cousin - and nemesis - the Supreme Court found that the law granting them the authority to the hear the case to be unconstitutional and dismissed the case. <br /><br /> Chief Justice John Marshall first explained that &ldquo;The government of the United States has been emphatically termed a government of laws, and not of men.&rdquo; <br /><br /> Marshall also explained that under the doctrine of separation of powers and the inherent judicial power of the Supreme Court, that the Supreme Court would be the final arbitrator of what the law means: <blockquote>It is emphatically the province and the duty of the judicial department to say what the law is. Those who apply the rule to particular cases, must of necessity expound and interpret that rule. If two laws conflict with each other, the courts must decide on the operation of each. . . This is the very essence of judicial duty.</blockquote> Because the Constitution was the paramount law of the land ratified by the people, Marshall found that Congress could not alter it through mere legislation: &ldquo;It is a proposition too plain to be contested, that the constitution controls any legislative act repugnant to it; or, that the legislature may alter the constitution by an ordinary act.&rdquo; Marshall continued, &ldquo;Between these alternatives there is no middle ground. The constitution is either a superior paramount law, unchangeable by ordinary means, or it is on level with ordinary legislative acts, and, like other acts, is alterable when the legislature shall please to alter it.&rdquo; <br /><br /> Those who oppose judicial review, Marshall explained, &ldquo;would subvert the very foundation of all written constitutions.&rdquo; Such a theory &ldquo;reduces to nothing what we deemed the greatest improvement on political institutions, a written constitution...&rdquo; <br /><br /> &ldquo;Thus,&rdquo; Marshall continued, &ldquo;the particular phraseology of the Constitution of the United States confirms and strengthens the principle, supposed to be essential to all written constitutions, that a law repugnant to the constitution is void; and that courts, as well as other departments, are bound by that instrument.&rdquo; <br /><br /> <i>Marbury v Madison</i> established the bedrock principles that the Constitution would govern the affairs of the government of the America, and that the Supreme Court would be the guardian of the supreme law of the land. </div> </div><!--/leftcolumn--> <div id="right_column"> <img src="images/marbury_madison.jpg" /> <div id="rightBodyBlock" class="disclaimer_text"></div> <br /> <div id="rightBodyBlock" class="body_text"> <ul> <li class="no_bullet"><a href="documents-speeches.html">The Vital Documents and Speeches</a></li> <li>September 11: <a href="declaration-of-independence.html">The Declaration of Independence</a></li> <li>September 12: <a href="marbury-madison.html">Marbury v Madison</a></li> <li>September 13: <a href="resolution-of-congress.html">Resolution of Congress</a></li> <li>September 14: <a href="seneca-falls-declaration.html">Seneca Falls Declaration</a> and <a href="19th-amendment.html">The 19th Amendment</a></li> <li>September 15: <a href="gettysburg-address.html">The Gettysburg Address</a>, <a href="emancipation-proclamation.html">Emancipation Proclamation</a> and <a href="i-have-a-dream.html">I Have A Dream</a></li> <li>September 16: <a href="bill-of-rights.html">The Bill of Rights</a></li> <li>September 17: <a href="original-constitution.html">Original Unamended Constitution</a> and <a href="9th-10th-amendments.html">The 9th & 10th Amendments</a></li> </ul> </div> <br /><br /> <div id="rightBodyBlock" class="tagline_text"><b>Help Renew the Spirit of America.</b></div> <div id="cta" onclick="location.href='join-the-effort.html';"></div> <div id="facebook"><a href="http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=119416264739170&ref=ts" target="_blank"><img src="images/facebook.jpg" alt="Find us on Facebook" /></a><br /><br /><a href="http://twitter.com/PatriotWeek"><img src="http://www.twitterbuttons.com/upload/badges/afd40ba764twitterbutton-0106.gif" title="By: TwitterButtons.com" alt="By: TwitterButtons.com" width="195"/></a></div> </div><!--/rightColumn--> <div style="clear:both"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div id="footer"> <div id="horiz_line"><img src="images/horiz_line.gif" width="900" height="1" align="absmiddle"/></div> <div id="footer_content" class="footer_text"> <b>About Patriot Week</b> <br />&#187; <a href="index.html">Home</a> <br />&#187; <a href="first-principles.html">First Principles</a> <br />&#187; <a href="founding-fathers-patriots.html">Founding Fathers/Patriots</a> <br />&#187; <a href="activities.html">Activities</a> <br />&#187; <a href="schedule.html">Patriot Week Schedule</a><br />&#187; <a href="2011-public-events.html">2011 Public Events</a> </div> <div id="vert_line"><img src="images/vert_line.gif" width="1" height="130" /></div> <div id="footer_content" class="footer_text"> <b>Patriot Week Resources</b> <br />&#187; <a href="materials-resources.html">Materials and Resources</a> <br />&#187; <a href="flags.html">Flags</a> <br />&#187; <a href="documents-speeches.html">Documents and Speeches</a> <br />&#187; <a href="original-constitution.html">Original Constitution</a> </div> <div id="vert_line"><img src="images/vert_line.gif" width="1" height="130" /></div> <div id="footer_content" class="footer_text"> <b>Participants & Organizers</b> <br />&#187; <a href="2010-participants.html">2010 Participants</a> <br />&#187; <a href="2009-participants.html">2009 Participants</a> <br />&#187; <a href="board-of-directors.html">Board of Directors</a><br />&#187; <a href="advisory-board.html">Advisory Board</a> <br />&#187; <a href="about-judge-warren.html">About Judge Warren</a> </div> <div id="vert_line"><img src="images/vert_line.gif" width="1" height="130" /></div> <div id="footer_content" class="footer_text"> <b>Media / News</b><br /> &#187; <a href="media-clips.html">Media Clips</a><br /> &#187; <a href="movies.html">Movies</a><br /> &#187; <a href="michigan-senate-resolution.html">2009 Michigan Senate Resolution</a><br /> &#187; <a href="2010-michigan-senate-resolution.html">2010 Michigan Senate Resolution</a><br /> &#187; <a href="2011-Michigan-Senate-Resolution.html">2011 Michigan Senate Resolution</a><br /> &#187; <a href="2010-michigan-house-resolution.html">2010 Michigan House Resolution</a><br /> &#187; <a href="2011-michigan-house-bill-4464.htm">2011 Michigan House Bill 4464</a><br /> &#187; <a href="2011-Michigan-Senate-Bill-282.html">2011 Michigan Senate Bill 282</a><br /> &#187; <a href="newspaper-articles.html">Newspaper Articles</a> </div> <div id="vert_line"><img src="images/vert_line.gif" width="1" height="130" /></div> <div id="footer_content" class="footer_text"> &#187; <b><a href="join-the-effort.html">Join the Effort</a></b> <br />&#187; <b><a href="contact-patriot-week.html">Contact Patriot Week</a></b> <br />&#187; <b><a href="http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=119416264739170&ref=ts" target="_blank">Find Us on Facebook</a></b> </div> <div id="end_cap"> <div class="copyright">&#169; 2010 Patriot Week</div> </div> </div><!--/footer--> <div id="end_cap_bottom"></div> </div><!--/wrapper--> </body> </html>